15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (2024)

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (1)

Whether you prefer it in the form of a stick, a pot or a palette, cream eyeshadow is a brill addition to your makeup bag for too many reasons to count.

It's awesome for, er, dry eye-lids

Firstly, if you, like me, are cursed with the burden of dry eyelids (it's a thing, look it up), you might find that eyeshadows (especially the metallic, glittery types) start out looking totally gorgeous, but by 4pm have dried up into a wrinkled, Saharan nightmare. I feel you. Cream eyeshadows are my solution to this issue. Make sure you opt for more moisturising, oil-based varieties (see #7 and #11 for an example) and they'll ensure the skin hosting your pigment stays nourished and glowy.

...But it's also a saviour for oily lids

But also, if you're of the oilier persuasion, you probably also suffer when it comes to keeping a beat looking fresh, with all your hard work melting at the literal blink of an eye. A hard-wearing cream eyeshadow might be a solution for you too, especially if you enlist the likes of #2 and #5, which are designed to withstand facial oil.

And if you're keen to keep things smudge-proof, set with translucent powder (or even a powder eyeshadow in a matching shade or a complementary shimmer/glitter). This technique is brilliant for dark, smokey eye looks – start out with a rich jewel tone cream shadow, and layer over greys and blacks for a multi-dimensional smoke.

It's the perfect base...

Speaking of which, cream eyeshadows are also a good option for priming your eyes, provided you have a nude option to hand. Pick out a shade which knocks out any distracting tones in your lids, and enjoy building up your look over a blank canvas – the dream.

...and it's an amazing blending aid

Whenever a highly pigmented shadow, dark or light, starts misbehaving on your lids (i.e. creeping too high towards your eyebrow or smudging too close to your nose), you can grab a clean blending brush and a nude cream shadow and use the pair to 'delete' areas of your eyeshadow that are ruining the shape - a saving grace if you're into experimenting, but not especially steady-handed.

Screwed up your make-up? It'll save the day there too...

A wise make-up artist once taught me there's no botched eyeshadow look that can't be fixed with a layer of shimmer. Cream shadow toppers are perfect for this, especially the new holographic/wet-look/shimmer-heavy options we're seeing on the market. Keep one in your bag at all times for any blending disasters – you'll never have a pre-party make-up breakdown again. Promise.

Ready to invest? Read on to meet your match.

1

Best cream eyeshadow for: a weightless finish

Rare Beauty Stay Vulnerable Liquid Eyeshadow

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (3)

This cream formula feels as light as whipped cream and avoids leaving lids feeling stiff or tight. Not only that but it's liquid to powder technology also impresses with just how little the texture sinks into fine lines (spoiler: it's zero!).

2

Best cream eyeshadow for: beauty on a budget

e.l.f. No Budge Cream Eyeshadow

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (4)

This 3-in-1 cream shadow, primer and liner will not only last you all day (and night!) but it won't break the bank, either. At just £5, you best believe we're adding more than one to our online shopping cart...

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

3

Best cream eyeshadow for: oily lids

Vieve Eye Wands, £21 each

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (5)

These wands are a neutral lover’s dream. Available in six shades you can combine the deeper shades for a blendable smoky eye or on lighter skin the three paler tones work as a great base for neutral looks.

4

Best cream eyeshadow for: a sheer finish

£15.00 Glossier Skywash

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (6)

As with everything that Glossier does, this sheer lid tint is a total life changer. It's a liquid-to-powder formula rather than a cream, but still imparts the same smooth, naturally looking colour wash.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

5

Best cream eyeshadow for: MUAs in the making

MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot Eye Shadow

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (7)

It's a cult pro secret for a reason. The shade Groundwork is your go-to buildable base for any look, from simple to all-out glam.

6

Best cream eyeshadow for: intense pigment

Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Colour

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (8)

If, like me, you're willing to do just about anything for an extra five minutes in bed, then look no further. This eyeshadow stick delivers effortless application (just scribble on and blend with your finger tip or a brush) with up to 12 hours of high-impact colour, too.

Good to go in a matter of seconds!

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

7

Best cream eyeshadow for: multi-use

Danessa Myricks Beauty Colorfix Cream 10ml

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (9)

You truly can't go wrong with a 3-4-1 bargain... and my Friday's Dominos order as well as the Danessa Myricks colourfix cream shadows are both evidence of that.

This small tube packs a punch with pigment that can be used not only as eyeshadow but eyeliner, lip colour, and blush, too! I mean, if it's gonna reduce time spent on makeup and save us some coin, you best believe we're all for it.

8

Best cream eyeshadow for: experimenters

Huda Beauty Matte & Metal Melted Shadows

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (10)

The queen of the cut crease knew what she was doing when she created this double-ended beauty. Lay down a highly pigmented pop with the matte end doe-foot, and add dimension using the opposite metallic end.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

9

Best cream eyeshadow for: party make-up

Hourglass Scattered Light Glitter Eyeshadow

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (11)

Look like you made a massive effort, when in fact you swiped this on your lid with your fingertips, finished with mascara and went to pre-drinks. Ideal.

10

Best cream eyeshadow for: no-mirror make-up

Beauty Pie Wondercolour Longwear Cream Eyeshadow Stick

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (12)

Designed perfectly for makeup on the go, this cream eyeshadow comes in a handy stick format, whilst the formula is utterly smudge-proof. There are sixteen shades to choose from, so plenty of choice whether you're feeling experimental or fancy playing it safe with a neutral shade.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

11

Best cream eyeshadow for: date make-up

Charlotte Tilbury Eyes to Mesmerise Cream Eyeshadow

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (13)

Made minimal effort for work and scheduled a last-minute Hinge date? Swipe a little of this shimmer on your lids and think no more of it.

12

Best cream eyeshadow for: on the go

Eye2Eye

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (14)

First of all, we love how easy these little pots are to stack up and collect. The shade fortitude is an impactful red with a hint of iridescent shimmer. It has great pigment so you only need a touch of it blended out.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

13

Best cream eyeshadow for: foolproof smokey eyes

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Shadow Stick

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (15)

If you're new to creamy formulas, stick with this absolute classic, decorated with awards left, right and centre. This one's great for smokey eyes, but there's a range of mauves, browns and peaches to pick from too.

14

Best cream eyeshadow for: matte eye looks

Too Faced Melted Chocolate Matte Liquid Eyeshadow

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (16)

These matte shadows are for you if you’re obsessed with a soft warm eye look as all the shades are a variation of choc. The formula is very long-wearing and pretty crease-proof if you don’t layer up too much. It’s also a good base for pressing on glitter or shimmer to ramp up your eye game.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

15

Best cream eyeshadow for: a crease-free wet look

Natasha Denona Chroma Crystal Top Coat

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (17)

This one's a game-changer. If you've tried (and failed) at the wet-look (I feel you, seriously), let this one give you hope. The shimmery, dynamic pigment is the perfect optical illusion to make you look like a sexy, sweaty Miley at Glastonbury.

15 of the best cream eyeshadows that always deliver long lasting colour (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Greg O'Connell

Last Updated:

Views: 5414

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (62 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Greg O'Connell

Birthday: 1992-01-10

Address: Suite 517 2436 Jefferey Pass, Shanitaside, UT 27519

Phone: +2614651609714

Job: Education Developer

Hobby: Cooking, Gambling, Pottery, Shooting, Baseball, Singing, Snowboarding

Introduction: My name is Greg O'Connell, I am a delightful, colorful, talented, kind, lively, modern, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.